PENTAX 17 vs LomoApparat: Which Half-Frame Film Camera?
By CameraMall | Published: 2026-10-23
Category: Comparisons
Compare the PENTAX 17 and LomoApparat half-frame film cameras: price, features, and which fits your shooting style.
Quick answer
Choose the PENTAX 17 for precise, durable half-frame shooting with twice the exposures per roll; pick the LomoApparat for playful, experimental wide-angle shots at a budget price.
Half-frame format: more shots per roll
Both cameras use a half-frame 35mm format, which records images at 17 x 24mm instead of the full 36 x 24mm. This means a standard 36-exposure roll yields approximately 72 shots—perfect for travel or everyday shooting without frequent reloads.
The PENTAX 17 is built around this format with a dedicated design, while the LomoApparat adapts it for a more casual, snapshot approach. Your choice depends on whether you value precision or spontaneity.
Lens and field of view: precision vs. wide-angle fun
The PENTAX 17's lens is designed for sharp, classic half-frame images, suitable for street and portrait photography. In contrast, the LomoApparat's 21mm wide-angle lens lets you fit more into the frame—ideal for landscapes, group shots, and creative compositions.
If you want a camera that encourages experimentation, the LomoApparat's wide view and accessory options (like the kaleidoscope and splitzer) offer creative flexibility. If you prefer a more traditional, controlled shooting experience, the PENTAX 17 is the better fit.
Price and build: investment vs. accessibility
The PENTAX 17 is priced at USD 354.96 (compare at USD 499.95), reflecting its robust build and thoughtful design. It's an investment for serious film enthusiasts. The LomoApparat, at USD 57.85 (compare at USD 89.00), is an affordable entry point for beginners or those wanting a playful backup camera.
If you're new to film and unsure about commitment, the LomoApparat lets you experiment without a big financial outlay. If you're ready to invest in a camera that will last and deliver consistent results, the PENTAX 17 is worth the price.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Precision vs. experimentation: The PENTAX 17 gives you reliable, sharp images with a classic feel; the LomoApparat encourages creative effects and wide-angle shots. Decide which shooting style you value more: consistency or creativity.
- Price vs. features: The PENTAX 17 is a premium investment with a durable build; the LomoApparat is budget-friendly but offers fewer manual controls. If budget is tight, the LomoApparat is a low-risk start; if you want longevity, invest in the PENTAX 17.
- Portability vs. versatility: Both are compact, but the PENTAX 17's design focuses on classic half-frame shooting, while the LomoApparat adds wide-angle and accessory options. Consider what you'll shoot most: everyday snapshots or creative wide-angle scenes.
Product facts
- PENTAX 17 Half Frame Camera (Dark Silver): The Pentax 17 offers a compact 17 x 24mm recording area, allowing a 36-exposure roll to yield approximately 72 shots. You can shoot twice as many frames per roll, making it economical and convenient for long trips or everyday use.
PENTAX 17 Half Frame Camera (Dark Silver) - LomoApparat 21mm Wide-angle Camera: The LomoApparat features a 21mm wide-angle lens and a built-in flash with colored gel filter slider, plus accessories like a close-up lens and kaleidoscope. It's designed for creative, experimental photography straight out of the box, perfect for playful and spontaneous shots.
LomoApparat 21mm Wide-angle Camera
Who should buy which?
Best for
- PENTAX 17: Film enthusiasts who want a reliable, precise half-frame camera for daily shooting.
- LomoApparat: Beginners and creative shooters who want an affordable, fun camera with wide-angle and experimental features.
Not for
- PENTAX 17: Budget-conscious buyers or those who prefer a more casual, experimental approach.
- LomoApparat: Photographers needing sharp, controlled images or manual settings.
